Top Story Local

Camacho declines Secharmidal plea deal over self-defense claim

Mark Rabago •

November 20, 2026

•

3 min read

Superior Court Presiding Judge Joseph N. Camacho declined to accept murder defendant BinWei Zhang Secharmidal's proposed guilty plea to a reduced charge of voluntary manslaughter during a change-of-plea hearing on Nov. 18, 2026, after the accused maintained that he acted in self-defense during the fatal confrontation.

Secharmidal, also known as "Joe Secharmidal," is accused of killing Sheldon Kaianoa, 45, following an argument along Asusena Avenue in Garapan last May 2.

During the hearing, Chief Prosecutor Chester Hinds presented an amended charge of voluntary manslaughter, which carries a maximum prison sentence of 10 years, instead of the original murder charge.

However, when Camacho asked Secharmidal to explain what happened during the confrontation, the 33-year-old defendant insisted that he was defending himself.

"I defended myself on the incident," Secharmidal told the court.

He also said, "I left the victim breathing."

His statements prompted Camacho to question whether the court could accept the proposed guilty plea when Secharmidal was maintaining that his actions were justified.

The judge explained that voluntary manslaughter involves an unlawful killing committed during a sudden quarrel or in the heat of passion following adequate provocation, which is legally different from a killing committed in self-defense.

Camacho clarified that he was not making a determination on the merits of Secharmidal's account, but that the court needed a sufficient factual basis before accepting a guilty plea.

Acting chief public defender Robert McNeil subsequently raised the possibility of an Alford plea, which allows a defendant to accept a criminal conviction without admitting factual guilt.

Rather than immediately consider that option, Camacho continued the change-of-plea hearing to Dec. 16, giving the parties additional time to determine how to proceed.

The judge emphasized that any decision to plead guilty must be made knowingly and voluntarily, without Secharmidal feeling pressured to accept an agreement simply to avoid trial.

The proposed plea agreement remains unresolved, and the court has not accepted a guilty plea.

As previously reported, Department of Public Safety officers responded to a 911 call shortly before 11:30pm on May 2 about a disturbance along Asusena Avenue.

Responding officers found Kaianoa unresponsive on the roadway with multiple injuries. Emergency personnel attempted to revive him before transporting him to the Commonwealth Health Center, where he was pronounced dead.

Police said Secharmidal and Kaianoa had been drinking together at a Garapan establishment before leaving on foot.

Investigators alleged that an argument between the two men escalated into a physical confrontation. Secharmidal was subsequently located in Susupe, taken into custody, and charged with murder.

Secharmidal pleaded not guilty during his June 10 arraignment.

At an earlier hearing on May 5, Associate Judge Kenneth L. Govendo maintained his bail at $200,000 and denied a defense request to allow a 10% bond.

During an Oct. 14 hearing, Hinds confirmed to Marianas Press that the government had extended a plea offer to the defense.

Secharmidal's jury trial had previously been scheduled for Dec. 7, although both sides were exploring a possible agreement that could resolve the case without a trial.

The next change-of-plea hearing on Dec. 16 is expected to clarify whether the parties can proceed with an acceptable plea or whether the murder case will move toward trial.

Secharmidal remains in custody at the Department of Corrections.


Share this article: